Latino USA Arts Visualization Project

Bread and Roses - Latino USA Episode 425

This segment was featured on Episode 425, which aired on June 6, 2001. It is a reporter package about the film.

Caption: Bread and Roses Movie Poster. Credit: The Labor Film Database
Bread and Roses Movie Poster. Credit: The Labor Film Database

Bread and Roses is a film by Ken Loach released September 14, 2000. 

Plot overview: “In Los Angeles, illegal Mexican immigrant Maya (Pilar Padilla) finds work as a janitor through her sister, Rosa (Elpidia Carrillo). However, since both work for a non-union company, conditions are grim. After putting up with abuse from her bosses, Maya is open to the pro-union rhetoric offered by organizer Sam Shapiro (Adrien Brody). Rosa, however, is far less interested in clashing with management, given the needs of her family, and a rift begins to form between the sisters.”

Additional Resources

Articles

Guzmán, Ricardo Andrés. “From Highways to High-Rises: The Urbanization of Capital, Consciousness and Labor Struggle in Ken Loach’s ‘Bread and Roses.’” Arizona Journal of Hispanic Cultural Studies, vol. 16, no. 16, 2012, pp. 101–18, https://doi.org/10.1353/hcs.2012.0034 .

Young, Elliott. “Reaction to R. Andrés Guzmán’s ‘From Highways to High-Rises: The Urbanization of Capital, Consciousness and Labor Struggle in Ken Loach’s Bread and Roses.’” Arizona Journal of Hispanic Cultural Studies, vol. 16, no. 16, 2012, pp. 119–20, https://doi.org/10.1353/hcs.2012.0040 .

Books

Gibney, Mark. Watching Human Rights : The 101 Best Films / Mark Gibney. 1st ed., Routledge, 2016, https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315631219.

Works Cited:

Bread and Roses. Fandango Media, n.d. Rotten Tomatoes. Accessed 29 Oct, 2025.

00:00 / 00:00

Annotations

00:00 - 00:07

As a group, immigrant workers are rarely seen and seldom heard in modern U.S. media.

Maria Hinojosa
Labor Organizing

00:07 - 00:11

Beginning June 1st, though, Bread and Roses will be released nationwide.

Maria Hinojosa
Bread and Roses
Year 2000

00:11 - 00:18

The bilingual film chronicles the struggle of immigrants to form a union in Southern California during the 1990s.

Maria Hinojosa
Bread and Roses
Southern California
The 1990s

00:18 - 00:20

The film premiered recently in Los Angeles.

Maria Hinojosa
Bread and Roses
Los Angeles

00:20 - 00:24

Correspondent Robin Yorovich was there and filed this report.

Maria Hinojosa

00:24 - 00:31

As Bread and Roses opens, its heroine, Maya Montenegro, played by Pilar Padilla, survives a dramatic border crossing.

Robin Yurovich
Pilar Padilla
Bread and Roses
Excerpt

00:43 - 00:50

Once in Los Angeles, she joins her sister, Rosa, played by Elpidia Carrillo, working as a janitor in a downtown high-rise. Soon, a union organizer comes calling.

Robin Yurovich
Elpidia Carrillo
Bread and Roses

00:52 - 00:59

Hi, is Rosa in? Yeah, Hold On. Mami! Que? Hay alguien en la puerta-

Bread and Roses
Pilar Padilla
Elpidia Carrillo
Excerpt

00:59 - 01:07

Hi, I'm Sam Shapiro, the Justice for Janitors campaign.

Bread and Roses
Adrien Brody
Excerpt

01:07 - 01:10

I'm Rosa, Justice for Rosa's campaign.

Bread and Roses
Elpidia Carrillo
Excerpt

01:10 - 01:19

Maya liked Sam, played by actor Adrien Brody and the idea of the union, but the more hardened and cynical Rosa is not so easily persuaded.

Robin Yurovich
Adrien Brody
Bread and Roses

01:19 - 01:24

There is every chance you can get fired. I've seen it before. What are you going to do? Pay the rent? Feed my kids?

Excerpt
Bread and Roses
Elpidia Carrillo

01:24 - 01:28

And you? You better keep away from this nice one. Listen, they will fire anyway!

Excerpt
Bread and Roses
Elpidia Carrillo

01:29 - 01:38

Nearly a decade after he came up with the idea for Bread and Roses, screenwriter Paul Laverty was back in Los Angeles for the film's opening party.

Robin Yurovich
Paul Laverty
Los Angeles

01:38 - 01:48

He'd just arrived from his state of Scotland in the early 90s when thousands of janitors, mostly from Mexico and Central America, were beginning to demand better pay and benefits.

Robin Yurovich
Paul Laverty
Labor Organizing
Los Angeles

01:49 - 01:54

I went along and I met the people. I met cleaners who were activists and trade union organizers.

Paul Laverty
Labor Organizing
Los Angeles

01:54 - 02:05

And they were fantastic people. And there was a kind of a spark to them that really got to me, you know, the way they organized and a real depth of human experience.

Paul Laverty
Labor Organizing
Los Angeles

02:05 - 02:10

You know, and there was a determination to organize and change their lives without making a fuss or playing victim.

Paul Laverty
Labor Organizing
Los Angeles

02:10 - 02:19

Laverty convinced director Ken Loach there was a film in the story of the janitors and he began poking around the union where he ran into organizer Jono Shaffer.

Robin Yurovich
Film
Ken Loach
Bread and Roses

02:19 - 02:27

The first time I met Paul, he sort of appeared and started asking a bunch of questions and I was totally suspicious about who this guy was, you know.

Jono Shaffer
Los Angeles
Bread and Roses

02:27 - 02:37

But over time he, you know, sort of wore on me. He said he was making a movie. I was like, yeah, right, everybody in L.A. is going to make a movie. You know, it's like this will end up in some trash can somewhere.

Jono Shaffer
Los Angeles
Bread and Roses
Film

02:37 - 02:48

Shaffer, who bears a resemblance to the film's organizer, says Laverty and Ken Loach took some artistic license, making the work of the organizer a little more reckless and spontaneous than it is in real life.

Robin Yurovich
Bread and Roses
Film
Jono Shaffer

02:48 - 02:54

But he says they didn't exaggerate the difficulty of organizing a union in the United States.

Robin Yurovich
Bread and Roses
Film
Labor Organizing

02:54 - 03:00

Real life janitor Dolores Sanchez says she saw a lot of herself and her co-workers in Bread and Roses.

Robin Yurovich
Bread and Roses
Film
Labor Organizing

03:01 - 03:10

I don't know. I cried during the whole movie because it does have several things that those of us from other countries have been through.

Dolores Sanchez
Bread and Roses
Labor Organizing

03:10 - 03:20

For the three and a half years it took to organize the union at her company, Sanchez says she went to work every night fighting her fears of a confrontation with the boss or of losing her job.

Robin Yurovich
Labor Organizing

03:20 - 03:28

During the three and a half years, I'd ask myself, if you lose your job, how are you going to support your kids?

Dolores Sanchez
Labor Organizing

03:28 - 03:39

Now Sanchez says the sacrifices of those years are paying off. She couldn't have a much wanted third child until she got family health insurance. Now she's got it and her baby's due late this summer.

Robin Yurovich
Labor Organizing

03:39 - 03:43

Bread and Roses mixes drama and fiction with reality.

Robin Yurovich
Bread and Roses

03:43 - 03:52

Director Ken Loach required the actors to work a shift alongside real life janitors, some of whom also appear in the movie along with other L.A. activists.

Robin Yurovich
Bread and Roses
Ken Loach

03:52 - 03:59

Si se puede, si se puede, si se puede...

Los Jornaleros del Norte
Music

03:59 - 04:09

In this scene at a union celebration, the music is provided by Los Jornaleros del Norte, five men who haven't quit their real life day jobs.

Robin Yurovich
Los Jornaleros del Norte
Music

04:09 - 04:15

They're members of L.A.'s day laborers union and they play their topical songs at labor and immigrant rights events.

Robin Yurovich
Los Jornaleros del Norte
Music

04:15 - 04:25

Bread and Roses has received mostly thumbs up from the critics, but as a business venture, it's a little risky, says its distributor Tom Ortenberg of Lionsgate Films.

Robin Yurovich
Bread and Roses

04:25 - 04:41

It doesn't have Tom Cruise or Mel Gibson, it doesn't have a lot of action, it's got a political bent to it about union organizing and those just aren't easy things. It's not a popcorn, bubble gum kind of movie.

Tom Ortenberg
Bread and Roses
Labor Organizing
Film

04:41 - 04:52

The film was made independently, backed by a group of investors from Europe, but says Ortenberg he hopes it's successful enough at the box office to convince Hollywood to take on similar projects.

Robin Yurovich
Bread and Roses
Film
Hollywood

04:52 - 04:59

Bread and Roses debuts June 1st in 15 to 18 cities across the country with more to follow in the coming weeks.

Robin Yurovich
Bread and Roses
Film

04:59 - 05:03

For Latino USA, I'm Robin Yurovich in Los Angeles.

Robin Yurovich

Project By: Kathryn Gaylon, Luz Gonzalez, Christian Nicholas, and Allysa Tellez
This site was generated by AVAnnotate