Bread and Roses - Latino USA Episode 425
This segment was featured on Episode 425, which aired on June 6, 2001. It is a reporter package about the film.

Bread and Roses is a film by Ken Loach released September 14, 2000.
Plot overview: “In Los Angeles, illegal Mexican immigrant Maya (Pilar Padilla) finds work as a janitor through her sister, Rosa (Elpidia Carrillo). However, since both work for a non-union company, conditions are grim. After putting up with abuse from her bosses, Maya is open to the pro-union rhetoric offered by organizer Sam Shapiro (Adrien Brody). Rosa, however, is far less interested in clashing with management, given the needs of her family, and a rift begins to form between the sisters.”
Additional Resources
Articles
Guzmán, Ricardo Andrés. “From Highways to High-Rises: The Urbanization of Capital, Consciousness and Labor Struggle in Ken Loach’s ‘Bread and Roses.’” Arizona Journal of Hispanic Cultural Studies, vol. 16, no. 16, 2012, pp. 101–18, https://doi.org/10.1353/hcs.2012.0034 .
Young, Elliott. “Reaction to R. Andrés Guzmán’s ‘From Highways to High-Rises: The Urbanization of Capital, Consciousness and Labor Struggle in Ken Loach’s Bread and Roses.’” Arizona Journal of Hispanic Cultural Studies, vol. 16, no. 16, 2012, pp. 119–20, https://doi.org/10.1353/hcs.2012.0040 .
Books
Gibney, Mark. Watching Human Rights : The 101 Best Films / Mark Gibney. 1st ed., Routledge, 2016, https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315631219.
Works Cited:
Bread and Roses. Fandango Media, n.d. Rotten Tomatoes. Accessed 29 Oct, 2025.
Annotations
00:00 - 00:07
As a group, immigrant workers are rarely seen and seldom heard in modern U.S. media.
00:07 - 00:11
Beginning June 1st, though, Bread and Roses will be released nationwide.
00:11 - 00:18
The bilingual film chronicles the struggle of immigrants to form a union in Southern California during the 1990s.
00:18 - 00:20
The film premiered recently in Los Angeles.
00:20 - 00:24
Correspondent Robin Yorovich was there and filed this report.
00:24 - 00:31
As Bread and Roses opens, its heroine, Maya Montenegro, played by Pilar Padilla, survives a dramatic border crossing.
00:43 - 00:50
Once in Los Angeles, she joins her sister, Rosa, played by Elpidia Carrillo, working as a janitor in a downtown high-rise. Soon, a union organizer comes calling.
00:52 - 00:59
Hi, is Rosa in? Yeah, Hold On. Mami! Que? Hay alguien en la puerta-
00:59 - 01:07
Hi, I'm Sam Shapiro, the Justice for Janitors campaign.
01:07 - 01:10
I'm Rosa, Justice for Rosa's campaign.
01:10 - 01:19
Maya liked Sam, played by actor Adrien Brody and the idea of the union, but the more hardened and cynical Rosa is not so easily persuaded.
01:19 - 01:24
There is every chance you can get fired. I've seen it before. What are you going to do? Pay the rent? Feed my kids?
01:24 - 01:28
And you? You better keep away from this nice one. Listen, they will fire anyway!
01:29 - 01:38
Nearly a decade after he came up with the idea for Bread and Roses, screenwriter Paul Laverty was back in Los Angeles for the film's opening party.
01:38 - 01:48
He'd just arrived from his state of Scotland in the early 90s when thousands of janitors, mostly from Mexico and Central America, were beginning to demand better pay and benefits.
01:49 - 01:54
I went along and I met the people. I met cleaners who were activists and trade union organizers.
01:54 - 02:05
And they were fantastic people. And there was a kind of a spark to them that really got to me, you know, the way they organized and a real depth of human experience.
02:05 - 02:10
You know, and there was a determination to organize and change their lives without making a fuss or playing victim.
02:10 - 02:19
Laverty convinced director Ken Loach there was a film in the story of the janitors and he began poking around the union where he ran into organizer Jono Shaffer.
02:19 - 02:27
The first time I met Paul, he sort of appeared and started asking a bunch of questions and I was totally suspicious about who this guy was, you know.
02:27 - 02:37
But over time he, you know, sort of wore on me. He said he was making a movie. I was like, yeah, right, everybody in L.A. is going to make a movie. You know, it's like this will end up in some trash can somewhere.
02:37 - 02:48
Shaffer, who bears a resemblance to the film's organizer, says Laverty and Ken Loach took some artistic license, making the work of the organizer a little more reckless and spontaneous than it is in real life.
02:48 - 02:54
But he says they didn't exaggerate the difficulty of organizing a union in the United States.
02:54 - 03:00
Real life janitor Dolores Sanchez says she saw a lot of herself and her co-workers in Bread and Roses.
03:01 - 03:10
I don't know. I cried during the whole movie because it does have several things that those of us from other countries have been through.
03:10 - 03:20
For the three and a half years it took to organize the union at her company, Sanchez says she went to work every night fighting her fears of a confrontation with the boss or of losing her job.
03:20 - 03:28
During the three and a half years, I'd ask myself, if you lose your job, how are you going to support your kids?
03:28 - 03:39
Now Sanchez says the sacrifices of those years are paying off. She couldn't have a much wanted third child until she got family health insurance. Now she's got it and her baby's due late this summer.
03:39 - 03:43
Bread and Roses mixes drama and fiction with reality.
03:43 - 03:52
Director Ken Loach required the actors to work a shift alongside real life janitors, some of whom also appear in the movie along with other L.A. activists.
03:52 - 03:59
Si se puede, si se puede, si se puede...
03:59 - 04:09
In this scene at a union celebration, the music is provided by Los Jornaleros del Norte, five men who haven't quit their real life day jobs.
04:09 - 04:15
They're members of L.A.'s day laborers union and they play their topical songs at labor and immigrant rights events.
04:15 - 04:25
Bread and Roses has received mostly thumbs up from the critics, but as a business venture, it's a little risky, says its distributor Tom Ortenberg of Lionsgate Films.
04:25 - 04:41
It doesn't have Tom Cruise or Mel Gibson, it doesn't have a lot of action, it's got a political bent to it about union organizing and those just aren't easy things. It's not a popcorn, bubble gum kind of movie.
04:41 - 04:52
The film was made independently, backed by a group of investors from Europe, but says Ortenberg he hopes it's successful enough at the box office to convince Hollywood to take on similar projects.
04:52 - 04:59
Bread and Roses debuts June 1st in 15 to 18 cities across the country with more to follow in the coming weeks.
04:59 - 05:03
For Latino USA, I'm Robin Yurovich in Los Angeles.